Skip to main content

Scientists Discover Way to Send Information into Black Holes Without Using Energy

Scientists Find a Way to Check Whether Quantum Computers Are Actually Getting the Right Answers

Quantum computers are becoming increasingly powerful, opening the door to solving scientific problems that would overwhelm even the world's most advanced conventional computers. But this progress has created an important challenge: How can scientists know whether a quantum computer is producing correct results when traditional computers are no longer powerful enough to check them?

Now, an international team of researchers has developed a promising technique that could help solve this problem. The new method allows scientists to measure the uncertainty in quantum simulations and calculate how accurately they are performing. In other words, instead of simply accepting a quantum computer's answer, researchers can now estimate how much they can trust it.

The technique has already been demonstrated using a quantum simulator containing up to 51 qubits, marking an important step toward making large-scale quantum simulations more reliable.

The Growing Problem of Verifying Quantum Computers

Quantum computers work differently from conventional computers. Traditional computers process information using bits, which represent either 0 or 1. Quantum computers use quantum bits, or qubits, which can exist in combinations of 0 and 1 through a property called superposition.

By using quantum effects such as superposition and entanglement, these machines can investigate certain complex problems much more efficiently than conventional computers.

One particularly promising application is quantum simulation. Scientists can use specialized quantum systems to reproduce the behavior of other quantum systems, helping them investigate complicated interactions between particles, materials, and physical forces.

However, there is a problem.

When a quantum simulation involves only a small number of qubits, researchers can compare its results with calculations performed on conventional computers. This provides a way to check whether the quantum system is behaving as expected.

But as the number of qubits increases, the calculations required to reproduce the same quantum behavior become extremely demanding. Eventually, conventional computers may no longer be capable of independently calculating the correct answer.

This creates a difficult situation. Quantum computers might produce results that conventional machines cannot verify, leaving scientists uncertain about how accurate those results really are.

A New Method That Measures Quantum Uncertainty

To address this challenge, an international research team led by Tristan Kraft at the Technical University of Munich and Peter Zoller at the University of Innsbruck, working with Barbara Kraus of the Technical University of Munich, developed a new experimental verification technique.

The method focuses on understanding how a quantum simulator actually behaves rather than assuming that it operates perfectly.

In real experiments, quantum systems are affected by several sources of error. Interactions between particles may differ slightly from theoretical predictions. The surrounding environment can disturb the system, while measurement instruments also introduce uncertainty.

These small imperfections can influence the final simulation results.

Instead of ignoring these problems, the researchers developed a way to measure them.

First, they collect experimental measurements from the quantum simulator. These measurements help reconstruct the system's behavior, including the important interactions between particles and the effects of environmental disturbances.

Next, researchers build a model based on the experimental data. They then calculate how uncertainties in that model could influence the final simulation results.

This allows the quantum simulator to provide more than just a numerical answer. It can also provide an estimated error margin, showing how much uncertainty is associated with that answer.

For example, imagine a quantum simulation predicts that a particular physical quantity has a value of 100. Instead of presenting 100 as a perfectly accurate result, the method could provide an uncertainty range around that prediction.

This gives scientists a better understanding of how reliable the result is, even when a conventional computer cannot independently reproduce the entire calculation.

Successfully Demonstrated Using 51 Qubits

To test their approach, the researchers initially worked with a relatively small quantum system containing ten trapped ions.

Trapped-ion quantum computers use electrically charged atoms held in place using electromagnetic fields. These ions can function as qubits, while carefully controlled laser operations allow researchers to manipulate their quantum states.

Because a ten-ion system is still manageable for conventional computers, the researchers could independently calculate its behavior and compare those calculations with the experimentally reconstructed model.

This provided an opportunity to test whether the new method could correctly identify uncertainties and produce meaningful error limits.

After validating the approach, the team moved to a much larger system containing 51 trapped ions.

The experiment was conducted in Innsbruck, Austria, using an ion-trap quantum simulator. A team led by Manoj Joshi and Christian Roos carried out the larger demonstration.

The results showed that the technique could also be applied to substantially larger quantum systems.

This is particularly important because verifying quantum simulations becomes increasingly difficult as the number of particles grows. The successful demonstration suggests that scientists may be able to evaluate the reliability of quantum simulations without depending entirely on conventional computers.

Why This Matters for the Future of Quantum Computing

The ability to measure uncertainty could become an essential part of future quantum computing research.

Simply increasing the number of qubits does not automatically mean that a quantum computer is becoming more useful. A machine might simulate thousands of interacting particles, but if scientists cannot determine whether its predictions are accurate, the practical value of those results remains uncertain.

The new technique offers a way to address this issue by providing experimentally determined error margins.

This could be particularly valuable in areas such as materials science, chemistry, and fundamental physics, where quantum simulations may help researchers understand complex systems that are extremely difficult to investigate using conventional calculations.

For example, scientists could eventually use more reliable quantum simulations to study how electrons interact inside advanced materials, investigate complicated molecular structures, or explore physical phenomena that remain poorly understood.

However, the researchers are not stopping at 51 qubits.

The Next Step: Two-Dimensional Quantum Simulators

The next major goal is to extend the technique to two-dimensional quantum simulators.

Unlike a simple chain of particles, two-dimensional systems can reproduce more complicated interactions and collective behaviors. This makes them particularly useful for studying complex quantum phenomena.

However, their increasing complexity also makes independent verification much harder.

Peter Zoller explains that classical calculations become significantly more difficult as the number of particles increases. As a result, experimentally determining the uncertainty in quantum simulation results becomes increasingly important.

Researchers are now working to adapt their approach for newer generations of two-dimensional quantum simulators, which offer improved precision and can investigate larger quantum systems.

If successful, this could provide scientists with a practical way to evaluate increasingly powerful quantum simulations.

A New Way to Measure Quantum Advantage

The research could also influence how scientists define and measure quantum advantage.

Quantum advantage refers to situations where a quantum computer can perform a particular task more effectively than a conventional computer.

Until now, discussions about quantum computing progress have often focused on processing speed, the number of qubits, and the complexity of problems that quantum machines can handle.

But speed alone does not guarantee a useful result.

A quantum simulator that produces an answer quickly but cannot demonstrate its accuracy may be less valuable than a slower system that provides a reliable answer with a clearly defined uncertainty range.

The researchers suggest that future comparisons between quantum and classical computers should consider not only how quickly they solve problems but also how accurately they produce verifiable results.

This could establish a more meaningful standard for evaluating progress in quantum computing.

The Road Ahead

The new technique does not completely eliminate errors from quantum computers, nor does it guarantee that every quantum simulation will be correct. Instead, it provides a systematic way to understand experimental imperfections and estimate how they affect the final results.

That distinction is important. As quantum computers move beyond the capabilities of conventional verification, scientists will need new methods to establish confidence in their predictions.

By demonstrating their approach on a 51-qubit quantum simulator, the researchers have taken an important step toward that goal.

The findings, published in the journal Physical Review X, could help make future quantum simulations more trustworthy and bring scientists closer to using quantum computers for problems that conventional machines cannot solve efficiently.

Reference:

  1. Tristan Kraft, Manoj K. Joshi, William T. Lam, Tobias Olsacher, Florian Kranzl, Johannes Franke, Lata Kh Joshi, Rainer Blatt, Augusto Smerzi, Daniel Stilck França, Benoît Vermersch, Barbara Kraus, Christian F. Roos, Peter Zoller. Bounded-Error Quantum Simulation via Hamiltonian and Lindbladian Learning. Physical Review X, 2026; 16 (3) DOI: 10.1103/s96t-n8tx

Comments

Popular

Scientists Discover Way to Send Information into Black Holes Without Using Energy

For years, scientists believed that adding even one qubit (a unit of quantum information) to a black hole needed energy. This was based on the idea that a black hole’s entropy must increase with more information, which means it must gain energy. But a new study by Jonah Kudler-Flam and Geoff Penington changes that thinking. They found that quantum information can be teleported into a black hole without adding energy or increasing entropy . This works through a process called black hole decoherence , where “soft” radiation — very low-energy signals — carry information into the black hole. In their method, the qubit enters the black hole while a new pair of entangled particles (like Hawking radiation) is created. This keeps the total information balanced, so there's no violation of the laws of physics. The energy cost only shows up when information is erased from the outside — these are called zerobits . According to Landauer’s principle, erasing information always needs energy. But ...

Black Holes That Never Dies

Black holes are powerful objects in space with gravity so strong that nothing can escape them. In the 1970s, Stephen Hawking showed that black holes can slowly lose energy by giving off tiny particles. This process is called Hawking radiation . Over time, the black hole gets smaller and hotter, and in the end, it disappears completely. But new research by Menezes and his team shows something different. Using a theory called Loop Quantum Gravity (LQG) , they studied black holes with quantum corrections. In their model, the black hole does not vanish completely. Instead, it stops shrinking when it reaches a very small size. This leftover is called a black hole remnant . They also studied something called grey-body factors , which affect how much energy escapes from a black hole. Their findings show that the black hole cools down and stops losing mass once it reaches a minimum mass . This new model removes the idea of a “singularity” at the center of the black hole and gives us a better ...

How Planetary Movements Might Explain Sunspot Cycles and Solar Phenomena

Sunspots, dark patches on the Sun's surface, follow a cycle of increasing and decreasing activity every 11 years. For years, scientists have relied on the dynamo model to explain this cycle. According to this model, the Sun's magnetic field is generated by the movement of plasma and the Sun's rotation. However, this model does not fully explain why the sunspot cycle is sometimes unpredictable. Lauri Jetsu, a researcher, has proposed a new approach. Jetsu’s analysis, using a method called the Discrete Chi-square Method (DCM), suggests that planetary movements, especially those of Earth, Jupiter, and Mercury, play a key role in driving the sunspot cycle. His theory focuses on Flux Transfer Events (FTEs), where the magnetic fields of these planets interact with the Sun’s magnetic field. These interactions could create the sunspots and explain other solar phenomena like the Sun’s magnetic polarity reversing every 11 years. The Sun, our closest star, has been a subject of scient...