Skip to main content

Scientists Discover Way to Send Information into Black Holes Without Using Energy

How Do Neutron Stars Stay So Hot?

Neutron stars are very dense and hot objects formed after big stars explode. When they are in a binary system, they pull matter from their companion star. This falling matter heats up the neutron star, both on the surface and deep inside. Scientists want to understand how this heat moves through the star, but the process is complex and slow to simulate using traditional computer models. A team led by Martin Nava-Callejas has now created a faster and simpler way to study this. They used stationary models, which assume the star’s heat stays steady over time. This helps calculate how heat flows between the outer layer and the inside of the star. Their method showed something interesting: heat can sometimes flow inward from the surface instead of outward. This happens when the outer layers are hotter than the crust. They also confirmed that an extra heat source, called shallow heating, is needed to explain what we see in real neutron stars. This new method saves time and helps scientists study more stars in different situations. It improves our understanding of how neutron stars heat up and cool down, especially after they stop collecting matter.


Neutron stars are some of the hottest and most mysterious objects in the universe. When they pull in matter from a nearby star in a binary system, they undergo intense heating deep inside. Scientists have been trying to understand how this heating happens and how it affects the star’s temperature over time. Recently, Martin Nava-Callejas and his team introduced a new method to simulate how heat moves through these stars, making it easier to study the long-term behavior of these cosmic powerhouses.

This article explains their work, walking you through the heat sources in neutron stars, the problems in simulating them, and how this new method brings new hope to astrophysics.

How Do Neutron Stars Stay So Hot?

1. What Are Neutron Stars and Why Do They Get So Hot?

Neutron stars are the dense remains of massive stars that exploded as supernovae. A neutron star is incredibly small and heavy – imagine a spoonful of it weighing billions of tons!

Many neutron stars live in binary systems, where they pull matter from a companion star. This process is called accretion. As this matter falls onto the neutron star, it creates huge amounts of heat.

Here’s how the heating works:

  • At the surface: Matter crashes into the star at high speed, releasing 100–200 MeV (million electron volts) of energy per particle. This causes the surface to heat up to 10–20 million degrees Kelvin.

  • Deeper inside: The pressure from incoming matter leads to nuclear reactions, like hydrogen and helium burning, which can heat the star even more.

But this heating doesn’t stop at the surface. It travels into the star's crust and core, creating complex temperature layers. Understanding how heat flows inside the star is the key to figuring out how neutron stars evolve.


2. The Challenge: Simulating This Heat Flow

Studying how heat flows inside a neutron star is not easy. It involves:

  • Thermonuclear burning (energy from reactions)

  • Deep crustal heating (energy from reactions deeper in the crust)

  • Neutrino cooling (energy lost through ghost-like particles called neutrinos)

Doing time-dependent simulations that include all of these is very slow and takes a lot of computer power. As a result, scientists have only been able to simulate a few models at a time.

This makes it hard to explore different scenarios – like how the heat changes when the mass accretion rate goes up or down, or when different materials are involved.

That’s where Martin Nava-Callejas and his team come in.


3. A Smarter Way: Using Stationary Models

Instead of doing time-consuming simulations, the team developed a simpler method using stationary models. These models assume that the conditions inside the neutron star don’t change rapidly with time.

Here’s what they did:

  • They created stationary models that included thermonuclear burning and deep crustal heating.

  • They calculated the boundary conditions – that is, how heat flows between the outer envelope and the inner crust.

  • They tested their results by comparing them with the outcomes of MESA, a powerful code used for time-dependent simulations.

This allowed them to quickly explore many scenarios, changing things like:

  • The amount of matter falling onto the neutron star

  • How long the accretion lasts

  • How often it happens

  • The composition and properties of the crust and core


4. The Discovery: Heat Can Flow Both Ways

One of the most exciting findings from this new method is that heat doesn’t always flow from the inside out. Depending on the situation, heat can flow from the outer layers into the crust!

This happens when the outer envelope becomes hotter than the inner crust. Scientists call this a “temperature inversion”. It creates a negative luminosity at the base of the envelope – meaning energy is moving inward instead of outward.

This discovery confirms older predictions made in the 1980s but now proves that these strange heat flows can be studied more easily using the new method.


5. What Are the Heat Sources Inside the Star?

Let’s take a closer look at the different heat sources and what they do:

a) Surface Heating

When matter hits the surface, it heats it up instantly. But this heat escapes quickly as light and doesn’t go deep into the star.

b) Thermonuclear Burning in the Envelope

Just below the surface, hydrogen and helium burn either steadily or in bursts, raising temperatures to 100 million Kelvin.

c) Deep Crustal Heating

As more matter piles up, it squeezes the inner layers, triggering nuclear reactions like:

  • Electron captures

  • Neutron emissions

  • Pycnonuclear fusion

These reactions add 1–2 MeV of energy per particle deeper in the crust.

d) Shallow Heating

But even this isn’t enough to explain the hot temperatures observed in some stars. Scientists found there must be an additional heat source in the upper crust. This is called “shallow heating”.

Shallow heating can inject 1–3 MeV per particle, or even more in extreme cases like MAXI J0556-332, where up to 15 MeV were needed to match observations.


6. Why This Matters: Understanding Observations

When neutron stars stop accreting matter, they start to cool down. By watching how the surface cools over time, scientists can figure out what’s happening inside the star.

But previous models couldn’t match the observations unless they included this mysterious shallow heating.

The new method by Nava-Callejas and team makes it easier to explore how much shallow heating is needed, and how it changes with different conditions. It also explains why heat might move into the crust from the envelope, something older models couldn’t easily simulate.


7. Bursts, Superbursts, and Heating

Neutron stars sometimes have explosive events called Type I X-ray bursts, where the surface matter suddenly burns in a giant explosion.

Even bigger events, called superbursts, come from deeper down when carbon ignites.

To explain these events, models need extra heat in the crust. Otherwise, the fuel wouldn’t ignite. This extra heat is likely connected to the shallow heating described earlier.

The new method helps simulate these conditions better, giving scientists a more complete picture of how and where the energy is coming from.


8. What Causes Shallow Heating?

There are many possible sources of shallow heating:

  • Advanced nuclear reactions: Special fusion reactions involving heavy isotopes.

  • Turbulence: Fast-moving matter from the accretion disc may stir up the crust and create heat.

  • Magnetic effects: Changes in magnetic fields may release energy.

  • Convection: Movement of hot material could also help spread heat.

Each of these could play a role depending on the type of neutron star and the rate at which it’s gaining mass.


9. The Benefit: Simpler, Faster, and Broader Studies

Because this new method is much less time-consuming, scientists can now study many more neutron star models than before.

This means they can:

  • Test different types of stars

  • Try various accretion histories

  • Change crust and core properties

  • Understand the role of impurities and cooling by neutrinos

In short, it opens the door to much deeper understanding of neutron star evolution.


10. Conclusion: A New Chapter in Neutron Star Research

Martin Nava-Callejas and his colleagues have given the astrophysics community a powerful new tool to understand the inner workings of neutron stars.

By simplifying complex time-dependent simulations into easy-to-use boundary conditions, they make it possible to explore the thermal evolution of accreting neutron stars across a wide range of conditions.

Their work not only confirms old ideas like temperature inversion, but also helps explain mysterious heating patterns seen in real stars. With this method, scientists are now one step closer to solving the cosmic puzzle of neutron star heating.


Reference: Martin Nava-Callejas, Dany Page, Yuri Cavecchi, "Thermonuclear Heating of Accreting Neutron Stars", Arxiv, 2025. https://arxiv.org/abs/2505.02600


Technical Terms


1. Neutron Star

A neutron star is what’s left after a big star explodes. It's very small but super heavy — one spoonful of it can weigh more than a mountain!


2. Binary System

This is a system where two stars go around each other. One of them can be a neutron star, and it pulls matter from the other star.


3. Accretion

This means the neutron star is pulling in matter (like gas) from its partner star. This falling matter creates a lot of heat.


4. Thermonuclear Burning

This is when nuclear reactions happen on or near the surface of the neutron star — like hydrogen turning into helium. It releases a lot of heat.


5. Deep Crustal Heating

This is heating that happens deep inside the star’s outer layers (called the crust). As more matter piles on, it pushes the bottom layers and causes nuclear reactions, which heat the crust.


6. Shallow Heating

This is extra heating in the upper layers of the crust that scientists didn’t expect. It helps explain why some neutron stars stay hotter than expected.


7. Temperature Inversion

Normally, heat flows from hot to cold (inside to outside). But sometimes, the outer layers get hotter than the inside, and heat flows inward. This is called a temperature inversion.


8. Luminosity

This is a fancy word for how much energy a star gives off as light or heat. In this case, it helps tell us how heat moves inside the star.


9. MESA Code

This is a powerful computer program that helps scientists simulate stars and study how their temperatures and structures change over time.


10. Neutrino Cooling

Neutrinos are tiny invisible particles that carry away energy from the star. This makes the star cool down slowly.


11. Type I X-ray Burst

This is a sudden explosion on the neutron star's surface. It happens when too much fuel (like hydrogen and helium) builds up and burns all at once.


12. Superburst

This is a bigger version of a Type I burst. It comes from carbon burning deep in the crust and releases even more energy.

Comments

Popular

Scientists Discover Way to Send Information into Black Holes Without Using Energy

For years, scientists believed that adding even one qubit (a unit of quantum information) to a black hole needed energy. This was based on the idea that a black hole’s entropy must increase with more information, which means it must gain energy. But a new study by Jonah Kudler-Flam and Geoff Penington changes that thinking. They found that quantum information can be teleported into a black hole without adding energy or increasing entropy . This works through a process called black hole decoherence , where “soft” radiation — very low-energy signals — carry information into the black hole. In their method, the qubit enters the black hole while a new pair of entangled particles (like Hawking radiation) is created. This keeps the total information balanced, so there's no violation of the laws of physics. The energy cost only shows up when information is erased from the outside — these are called zerobits . According to Landauer’s principle, erasing information always needs energy. But ...

How Planetary Movements Might Explain Sunspot Cycles and Solar Phenomena

Sunspots, dark patches on the Sun's surface, follow a cycle of increasing and decreasing activity every 11 years. For years, scientists have relied on the dynamo model to explain this cycle. According to this model, the Sun's magnetic field is generated by the movement of plasma and the Sun's rotation. However, this model does not fully explain why the sunspot cycle is sometimes unpredictable. Lauri Jetsu, a researcher, has proposed a new approach. Jetsu’s analysis, using a method called the Discrete Chi-square Method (DCM), suggests that planetary movements, especially those of Earth, Jupiter, and Mercury, play a key role in driving the sunspot cycle. His theory focuses on Flux Transfer Events (FTEs), where the magnetic fields of these planets interact with the Sun’s magnetic field. These interactions could create the sunspots and explain other solar phenomena like the Sun’s magnetic polarity reversing every 11 years. The Sun, our closest star, has been a subject of scient...

Could Primordial Black Holes Have Formed from Aborted Phase Transitions?

Ai and colleagues propose a new way that primordial black holes (PBHs) could form in the early universe, using a mechanism that involves an "aborted phase transition." This takes place during the reheating phase after inflation, a period when the universe's temperature rises and then falls. During reheating, the universe is filled with a pressureless fluid called a reheaton. As the temperature rises to a maximum (Tmax), it surpasses the critical temperature needed for a phase transition, but not enough for bubbles to fully form and expand. These bubbles, which briefly nucleate as the temperature reaches Tmax, expand and then shrink as the temperature falls back below the critical level. When the bubbles shrink, they leave behind dense regions. These regions collect surrounding matter and eventually collapse into primordial black holes. The PBHs formed this way continue to grow in mass until the universe transitions into radiation domination. Primordial black holes (PBHs) ...